Most common fish. No bait needed
Can only be fished from ponds on islands. No bait needed.
Different variants available from different large islands on the map. No bait needed
Only found in the Ancient Isles region. Leech bait required
Only found in the Shores of Plenty region. Earthworms bait required.
Only found in the Devil's Roar region. Grub bait required.
Only found in the Wilds region. Earthworm bait required.
Only found near activate skeleton ships or Skeleton Forts. Grub bait required
Only found near shipwrecks. Earthworm bait required.
Only found in the middle of heavy storms. Leech bait required.
Can be dug up from grass or earth
Can be dug up from sand
Can be dug up from shorelines
Ashen Keys can be found from Ashen Key Guardians, randomly spawned on islands and a small chance from fishing. A key is required to unlock an Ashen Chest
Mermaid Gems are unique, as they have a fixed price, but can also be sold to ANY faction. It's recommended to sell them to the faction that you have the least reputation points towards, or your current emissary faction.